Event details from: Rob Schwitters (PSC) on instrumentalist tort law

Date
17 May 2022
Time
12:00 – 13:00

Abstract

What mainly divides recent philosophical accounts of tort law are those which consider tort law an instrument to further social goals (instrumentalism) and those which emphasize tort’s internal structure, in which only the individual interests of the plaintiff and defendant matter. Last mentioned position is often accompanied by a bold anti-instrumentalism, as in Weinrib’s and Beever’s account of civil liability in terms of corrective justice.

In this text I will argue that an anti-instrumentalist position is unrealistic and out of date because it does not do justice to the contemporary context in which liability is imposed. Social transformations since the nineteenth century have fundamentally affected the underlying rationale of tort law and made the relevance of instrumental concerns inevitable.

The relevance of instrumental concerns entails the promise of grounding civil liability on a wider range of normative concerns than when one merely focuses on the relationship between the individual litigants in a tort procedure. However, there are some concerns of those opposing instrumentalist accounts that need some further reflection. Building on Habermas’ theory of communicative action I will demonstrate that these concerns do not have to lead to a complete refutation of instrumentalist considerations. They address some problematic features of the institutional context in which today’s tort law is embedded.

Discussant: Laura Burgers

For more information please contact Roland Pierik (R.Pierik@uva.nl)