Event details from: Colloquium with Mateusz Grabarczyk

Date
24 October 2023
Time
12:00 – 13:00
Room
A3.01

Abstract
In many countries struggling with the turn towards authoritarianism, a kind of judges’ complicity in building non-democratic regimes can be observed. Theirbehaviour often manifests acceptance and even encourages the development of authoritarian state policy -the courts not only fail to defend human rights but legitimise (passively or actively) the laws and practices of the emerging regime. This raises the question: why do judges, often educated and appointed by democratic governments, facilitate and accept authoritarian power politics? In my presentation, using selected case studies (connected with transitional justice) and relatingthem to the present day (countries struggling with the so-called democratic backslidingwhich exemplifies the crisis of democracy), I will point to possible explanations for mentioned complicity. It is not, therefore, an answer to thequestion of what the judge actually did or could have done.I aim to indicatepossible explanatory factors as to why judges have acted and continue to act in the way they have in the face of the development of authoritarian state policies. Despite differences between particular cases such as history, legal system or legal culture, I think similar mechanisms and effects can be observed.I divide the basic explanations into followingmain categories: (1) factors related to the regime and the judges' fear for their safety; (2) related to personal preferences or political views; (3) related to defending the interests of a social group (class), and (4) related to the theory and philosophy of law, within which the most common point is made (often wrongly) legal positivism.