Colloquium with Elke Olthuis
Do judges experience conflict between impartiality and personal attitudes?
Details Date: 24 september 2024 Time: 13.00-14.00 Room: A3.01 (UvA Roeterseilandcampus REC) Discussant: Benjamin van Rooij
Event details from: Colloquium with Elke Olthuis
- Date
- 24 September 2024
- Time
- 13:00 – 14:00
- Room
- A3.01
Th is chapter addresses the question whether judges experience con ict between their im partiality and their personal attitudes in their professional judicial decision-making process. e chapter is laid out as follows. In section 2 a brief outline is provided of the Dutch legal framework regarding judicial impartiality and on the recusal and disquali cation of judges. Section 3 and 4 cover the analyses of the ndings from the semi-structured inter views with 77 Dutch rst instance court judges from all areas of law and three di erent courts of the interviews (on which the previous chapter was also based). e question was how judges experience their personal attitudes in relation to their impartiality, in light of the above-mentioned rules and, more particularly, whether the nd ings show that judges recuse themselves based on (internal) personal attitudes rather than externalities (mutatis mutandis in the sense of the objective test of partiality from the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR)). e conclusion is that participants in the interviews referred more o en to external reasons to question their impartiality, and less so to their internal experience or personal attitudes.