The legal experience of injustice with Dyzenhaus
David Dyzenhaus
In The Faces of Injustice, Judith Shklar criticizes the ‘normal model’ of justice which views injustice as ‘a prelude to or a rejection and breakdown of justice, as if injustice were a surprising abnormality’.2 Her central insight is that ‘the real realm of injustice … does not stand outside of the gates of even the best of known states. Most injustices occur continuously within the framework of an established polity with an operative system of law in normal times.’3 She adds a second, Hobbesian insight: ‘[w]ithout juridical institutions and the beliefs that support them, there can be no decent, just, or stable social relations, but only anxiety, mutual mistrust, and insecurity’.4 Since juridical institutions and their supporting beliefs may be necessary but insufficient to prevent injustice, the insights are consistent. Moreover, the centralization of power in the modern legal state gives to elites powerful instruments to do injustice they would otherwise lack. My chapter enquires into consistency, not as a matter of abstract logic, but of the logic of the legal experience of those in the ‘jural community’--the community of persons subject to the operation of a system of law.
Event details from: The legal experience of injustice with Dyzenhaus
- Date
- 18 October 2024
- Time
- 15:00 – 17:00
- Room
- A3.15